Local Government as a Platform – Cloud Architecture for 21st Century Local Digital Government
Local Digital – Transformation strategies for Local Government
Digital Transformation for Local Government in Scotland is represented by the Digital Office, formed following the work of the Local Government Digital Transformation Board. In this video Lorraine McMillan, CEO East Renfrewshire Council, provides a presentation on her role as Chair.
As we look across the whole of the UK we can identify the significant challenges local authorities face with regards to their digital strategies.
Ross Harling of Netitude goes as far as to say many are still stuck in the “digital stone age“, especially when assessed against those of towns and cities in the US, Canada, and Australia; in short a mostly internal view that doesn’t consider the transformative involvement of citizens or broader impacts of local economy regeneration that the technology investments can bring.
Problems include rudimentary IT issues such as running unsupported software, through poor online engagement practices: fewer than half of newly designed UK council web sites passing a SOCITM usability test, and half fail to provide a good online service for social care support for example.
In Scotland specifically the McLelland Report was a 2011 major review of IT spending, concluding:
“The key finding of the report was that the public sector is lagging where it should be and there is an opportunity to capture a multiplicity of benefits in radically changing how ICT is adopted and deployed and in how it enhances access to and improvements in the quality and value of services. Shared ICT platforms, a connection and spread of exemplar projects and enhanced engagement with the industry would reduce the proportion of cost invested in ICT by individual organisations and deliver local savings which might be partially reinvested in advancing the progress of ICT. It would also open the door to significant additional and wider savings in public sector costs by providing a platform for the operation of other shared services and better support sustainability goals.
The public sector should recognise that in the current economic environment a largely standalone and “self-sufficient” operating mode is no longer affordable and should commit to an era of sharing in ICT that will not only offer better value, but also still meet the needs of individual organisations and their customers.”
Small Pieces Loosely Joined
This describes the root issue which is repeated in the Policy Exchange report ‘Small Pieces Loosely Joined‘, notably:
“The report argues that the single greatest barrier to achieving technology-enabled reform is the sector’s fragmentation. Across England and Wales there are 375 local authorities, each with their own leadership, local links and priorities. Added to that, there are approximately 18,500 elected councillors, 1,783,500 local government employees and thousands of delivery teams providing more than 700 services.
Chapter 2 explains how, over many years, local authorities have separately procured or developed their own hardware, software and applications to enable them to carry out their functions and to deliver their services. As a result, though they all perform very similar tasks in their respective areas, each council’s IT architecture (the collection of software, hardware and processes it uses) is virtually unique to itself. This raises the cost of technology (through duplication, inefficiency and limiting economies of scale) and prevents local authorities from adopting – or rolling out at scale – the more efficient ways of working that could save significant money.“
In short each council spends on their own IT systems in an isolated silo fashion, duplicating what every other council is also doing despite each repeating the exact same functions.
Local GaaP – Government as a Platform
Therefore the remedy is as simple as the problem sounds, to eliminate duplication and build common systems that are shared between them, leading us to the concept of the ‘Government as a Platform‘ paradigm and applying it to local needs. To date it’s mainly been concentrated at the Central Government level, as documented here on their blog.
In it’s simplest form think of the SaaS (Software as a Service) model. This is how sharing of software needs is best achieved – Providers like Salesforce.com eliminated the need for their customers to each run their own duplicated CRM system by operating a single code base that is then shared between them.
So a Local Government SaaS equivalent would achieve the same – Each council has the same functional requirements, they run apps for numerous local services from waste collection through community centre bookings, and so this too could be served by a single code base the same way.
The challenge is that each has invested huge amounts into the duplicated data centre infrastructure required to run these apps, a resistance that has held up their adoption of Cloud computing.
However this prompts Aubrey De Graf’s quote: “Don’t Cling to a Mistake Just Because You Spent a lot of Time Making it”. Avoiding better, more efficient and transformative systems now simply because expensive investments were made in the past only means that that expensive mistake will be prolonged even more.
The tide is beginning to change. Early adopters have begun to embrace Cloud adoption and we’ll see this trend accelerate, and as we do this will create the opportunity for better designing these new Cloud systems to share common components and realize massive economies of scale as a result.
Sponsors of this article
- Transforming Government through AI and Data Science - October 31, 2018
- CSRA’s Migration to AWS GovCloud (US): An All-In Case Study - October 31, 2018
- How to Architect and Bring to Market SaaS on AWS GovCloud (US) - October 31, 2018
- Introduction to AWS GovCloud (US) - October 31, 2018
- How to Create a Cloud Adoption Framework - October 31, 2018
- What should be your Transformational Cloud Strategy? - October 31, 2018
- Canadian Digital Services – Open Source Playbook - October 31, 2018
- Canada’s Digital ID Future – A Federated Approach - October 31, 2018
- Welcome to Norfolk’s Open Data Portal - October 31, 2018
- Microsoft CEO: Trust is foundational to Open Data Initiative - October 31, 2018